When History Repeats Itself: Company Fined Over $800k for Decades of Warnings Ignored

It was just days before Christmas in 2023 when a wife began to worry. Her husband hadn’t returned home from his shift at the tank-cleaning company where he worked. Calls went unanswered.

Hours later, her worst fear was confirmed — he had been found unresponsive inside a tanker, overcome by carbon monoxide.

A life lost. A family broken. And for this company fined, it was another preventable tragedy.

A Familiar Pattern

Unfortunately, this wasn’t the company’s first fatality and far from their first offense.

The company had a long history of sending workers into confined spaces without adequate training, protective equipment, or air monitoring — and ignoring the consequences when things went wrong.

The company had a long history of sending workers into confined spaces without adequate training, protective equipment, or air monitoring — and ignoring the consequences when things went wrong. Despite years of citations, warnings, and opportunities to change, leadership failed to act.

December 1999: Two Workers Never Came Home

Almost exactly 24 years earlier, two men were sent to clean the inside of a tank that once held hazardous chemicals. They were given no respiratory protection.

When they didn’t come out, a coworker went to check on them and found both collapsed on the floor, overcome by toxic fumes. The company delayed calling for medical assistance for nearly four hours. Responders had to recover the bodies with masks and supplied air.

OSHA cited the employer and required retraining, PPE, and confined space procedures. The company agreed — but never followed through.

May 1999: The First Warning

Just months before that double fatality, another worker had already been injured in almost the exact same way.

He was told to enter a sludge tank with only a thin coverall, a shovel, and a bucket. Within minutes, he began suffering chemical burns and struggled to breathe.

Instead of helping, management refused to let him wash off or seek care. Hours later, he drove himself to the hospital. Alone.

That moment could have been the company’s turning point. But it wasn’t.

2023: A Tragedy Reborn

Fast forward 24 years. The same company. The same conditions. The same outcome.

A worker entered a tank without proper ventilation or monitoring. He never made it out. This time, OSHA issued $810,000 in penalties for eight repeat violations — but once again, the fines came too late to save a life.

Lessons Ignored Are Lessons Repeated

Unlike most of the articles in Occupational Lessons Learned/Cautionary Tales, this one doesn’t end with a traditional lesson that was learned. On the contrary, this company exhibited years of failing to learn a lesson at all.

safety failures rarely come from a lack of knowledge. They come from a lack of leadership.

But what we’ve learned and what we want others to learn is that safety failures rarely come from a lack of knowledge. They come from a lack of leadership.

This company had every opportunity to change course. They were warned, trained, cited, and even given specific corrective steps. But leadership chose inaction — and that choice led to devastating consequences.

Because when leaders don’t value safety, neither will their teams.

Why We Tell This Story

We tell this story for the leaders who may have relaxed their guard — who put off updating a safety program, postponed a refresher training, or assumed “it won’t happen here.” And we tell it for the workers who may recognize some of these same patterns in their own workplaces.

Speak up. Be your own advocate. If something feels unsafe, say so. If a policy hasn’t been followed, question it. The right to go home safe is not negotiable — and silence is never worth the risk.

At Cardinal, we ask ourselves, “Are You Willing?” Are you willing to risk your life? Are you wiling to risk the lives of others? Are you willing to stop making memories?

Article content

It’s an extreme question because we want to remind ourselves that there can extreme consequences for devaluing safety.

Prevention Starts Today

At Cardinal Compliance Consultants, we help organizations move beyond compliance to create cultures of accountability and care — because safety should never depend on luck. If your program needs a fresh set of eyes or your teams need confined space or leadership training, we’re ready to help guide you through creating safer operations. Contact a safety expert today.



from Cardinal Compliance Consultants https://cardinalhs.net/blog/company-fined-over-800k-decades-of-wrongdoing/
via Cardinal Compliance Consultants

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The 5 Types of Workplace Hazards: What Every Safety-Conscious Employer Needs to Know

Image
Every 7 seconds, a worker is injured on the job. For safety directors like Keith—who’s seen everything from chemical burns to crushed limbs—these aren’t just statistics; they’re nightmares that keep him up at 3 AM. The consequences of workplace hazards extend far beyond OSHA citations and fines. They affect your employees’ well-being, your productivity, your reputation, and ultimately, your bottom line. At Cardinal Compliance Consultants , we’ve spent over a decade helping businesses identify, evaluate, and control workplace hazards worldwide. With decades of experience our team of experts has seen firsthand how unaddressed hazards can derail operations and change lives forever. Understanding the five major categories of workplace hazards is the crucial first step toward creating a comprehensive safety program that truly protects your workforce. Whether you’re in construction, manufacturing, healthcare, or any industry where OSHA compliance matters (which is virtually all of them)...
Read more

Remember These Three Words When Having a Safety Conversation

Image
As we previously discussed in our last article, Leadership Participation in Incident Investigation: An Opportunity to Communicate Safety as a Value , leadership sends a positive message about the value of worker safety by participating in serious injury incident investigations. As described in the publication Better Safety Conversations , “Every day, safety conversations take place between executives and managers, between safety professionals and workers, and—most importantly—between front-line supervisors and the workers who report to them. These conversations have great potential for improving workplace safety and health.” Experiment with different approaches, build a library of safety phrases and stories, and have these conversations without fear. We all can actively participate by improving our safety communication skills and recognizing the opportunities to have positive safety conversations. Experiment with different approaches, build a library of safety phrases and stories, ...
Read more

Holiday Gifts & Lithium-Ion Battery Safety

Image
Holiday shopping season is in full swing, and there’s a good chance you may be considering or have already purchased a gift powered by lithium-ion (Li-ion) batteries. The amount of products containing lithium-ion batteries has increased in the marketplace due to their high energy density, meaning they can be smaller and lighter. However, what many fail to recognize is that the use of these batteries introduces potential safety risks and they require specific care during use and when disposing of them. This article is sure to bring you valuable information for safe-handling these batteries found in so many every-day household and workplace items. What Products Use Lithium-Ion Batteries? Lithium-ion batteries seem to be everywhere these days. You may not even realize you’re purchasing them when you snag more AA batteries by the register during checkout. They also supply power to many devices such as: E-bikes and e-scooters Cell phones, tablets, and laptops E-cigarettes and smoke...
Read more